Real Estate Blog/Real Estate/How to beat the stock market using this simple real estate strategy.

๐Ÿ  Stocks vs. Toronto Real Estate: What $196,000 invested Would Be Worth Today

If you had $196,000 to invest in 1993, would you have bought a Toronto home โ€” or invested it in the stock market?ย  โ€‹Letโ€™s break down exactly how both investments would have performed โ€” first with no leverage, and then using the powerful leverage real estate provides.ย  A few things to consider, I have taken into account for taxes, and fluctuations in both markets, this is not a complete insight into every stock, but rather the stock market as a whole, same thing with real estate, averages are not true values.

๐Ÿ’น Scenario 1: SPY ETF vs. Buying a Toronto Home (No Leverage)

๐Ÿ“Š Investment A: SPY ETF - SPY (tracks the S&P 500) launched in 1993.

-Price in 1993: ~$43
-Price in 2025: ~$560
-$196,000 invested in 1993 = ~4,558 shares

2025 Value: $2,553,000 (including dividends reinvested)

Total Gain: +1,203%

CAGR: ~10.3%

๐Ÿ  Investment B: Toronto Real Estate (Single Home)

-Average home price in 1993: $196,000
-Average price in 2025: ~$1,140,000

Total Gain: +481%

CAGR: ~6.4%

โš–๏ธ Verdict:ย  SPY ETF outperformed Toronto real estate if you bought a single home and held it with no mortgage or rental income.

๐Ÿ’ฅ Scenario 2: The Power of Leverage in Real Estate

This is where things get interesting. Real estate allows you to use leverage โ€” putting 25% down and borrowing the rest.ย  We took the same scenario, but used a mortgage to finance the balance:

Using the same $196,000:

-25% down = $49,000 per property
ย -$196,000 = enough for 4 homes
-1993 purchase value: $784,000 total

2025 market value: $4,560,000

Appreciation gain: $3,776,000

๐Ÿก Rental Income:

-$1,000/month per home ร— 4 homes = $4,000/month
-378 months (1993โ€“2025): $1,512,000
-After expenses (assume 40%): $907,200 net

๐Ÿงฎ Total Return:

-Property Value: $4,560,000
-Net Rental Income: $907,200

Total Wealth Created: $4,683,200

CAGR (approx.): ~11.7%

๐Ÿ Final Comparison Table

๐Ÿง  The Takeaway

Stocks have historically delivered strong returns, especially when dividends are reinvested. But real estate โ€” when leveraged properly and held long-term โ€” can offer greater total wealth, thanks to:

  • Property appreciation
  • Rental income
  • Mortgage paydown by tenants
  • Tax advantages
  • Control over your asset

If youโ€™re serious about building wealth, real estate offers you something the stock market canโ€™t: leverage and cash flow.ย  And if you need help in your journey, be sure to reach out to us here.

The Real Estate Blog...Continue Your Learning Journey

Stephen Headshot

Hi, I Am Stephen Young

CEO Of The Best Blog Ever

I have always loved real estate, and our blog gives you more information about real estate if you are looking for a deep dive. Here we interview other real estate investors, and we show you their journey from start to finish. Be sure to sign up for our weekly newsletter to keep up to date with all of the new blogs, interviews, and investment opportunities.

YR_IG_Elevation_July2020_1.jpg
Ebook 3D Cover
Ebook 3D Cover
YoungRealty_Logo_wht_FINAL (4).png

Real Estate...Made Simple!